The Best American Series has a spiffy website up today that has separate pages for each of the anthologies under that moniker. Each title has a details page which has two tabs, one that lists the pieces that will be fully included within the book, and the other listing the notable works, those that were considered, but not quite the favorites of the Guest Editor.
The series' most popular (I at least have heard this is the case, though have no sales figures to back this up) title, Best American Short Stories, was Guest Edited by Richard Russo this year. If I understand the process, that is, if it's the same as when Shannon Ravennel was the Series Editor, than Mr. Russo was presented with 120 short stories. He read them, selected his favorite 20, and boom, an anthology is ready to go with 20 short stories and 100 notable stories. I know that some Guest Editors come to the table with a story or two in mind, I believe I've read that both Michael Chabon and Stephen King brought some to the anthology that may not have been in that original 120.
A look through the 20 stories selected for inclusion this year finds that 12 whole journals are represented. Some shockers too: The New Yorker has two stories, and The Atlantic has a trio. Tin House is the big winner with four of their publishings being reproduced within the anthology. McSweeney's is another repeat offender with a trio as well. Continue looking through the names in the notables and you'll see each of these names appear again, along with a long list of journals--I didn't count, there is a great deal of repetition this year though, I'd venture to guess it's less than 100 total journals represented.
Narrative has a trio of notable stories. This makes them the King of the Online Journals as not one other online journal has published a story worthy of cracking the Top 120 this year according to the folks behind this anthology. Nothing from Guernica. Nothing from failbetter. No mentions of Storyglossia, or storySouth, or Joyland, or any of the 900 plus online journals you can find listed in the index of Best of the Web 2010.
Some visiting here will not have heard of BotW 2010. Maybe you haven't heard of the journals noted above, or many online journals. Here are two links to stories snagged from the BotW 2010 Table of Contents. Give them a peek and then you two can question how awesome things must be these days if there were 120 better stories published last year. Christine Schutt published "The Girl Needs to Be Kissed" in Blackbird and Stephen Graham Jones' "Modern Love" was captured by Everyday Genius.
The Best American Mysteries Stories major inclusions do not list the original source, so I have no idea how well they scan the online journal scene, but looking at their notables list (seemingly much lower than 100 stories), the only online only journal I could find listed was Thuglit, with two notable works.
None of the Best American Essays looked like they were from online journals either (though there were definitely some notable essays from online only journals).
This is not meant to be a slam on anybody that will find their name on any of the lists mentioned above (or in the Best Comics, Best Non-Required, Best Travel, Sports, Music, Poems, etc.), not at all. Their work has gone through astringent process and not only found a publishing home but also drew enough attention to be noted again in these year end anthologies. It's more a noticing and a reminder as to why the Best of the Web Series is important. The numbers above are skewed so greatly that it allows me to conclude not that the works published in online journals are being read and dismissed, but that they still are not truly being considered for these anthologies.
Recent Comments