Nice Things Said Re: EWN

  • "Dan Wickett is serious about a good read. But the EWN email list doesn't just deliver his sure-footed reviews; it also brings you news and connections to other writers. Sign up now - he understands what readers want to know about books." Quinn Dalton, author, Bulletproof Girl
  • 1.
    "Mr. Wickett is that rarely heard from but best of all possible reviewers - the dedicated and knowledgeable fan. He writes clean-cutting and fresh reviews that represent a sensibility unspoiled by over-exposure to the biz of books, but deeply in love with them." Daniel Woodrell, author, Winter's Bone
  • 3.
    "Dan Wickett is a reader's best friend. Not only does he read and trenchantly review new work, but he looks back to books that deserve ongoing readership. I've lost track of the number of times he's led me to boks that I overlooked (or never knew about), and that were a delight. There aren't many reviewers I will let shape my library, but Dan Wickett is one." Erin McGraw, author, The Baby Tree

Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter

    Blog Nation

    • Book Blogs

    LitBlogs

    Author Websites

    « Interview 2005-030: David Crouse | Main | Fobber Update - David Abrams »

    December 27, 2005

    Comments

    steven gillis

    Hey Dan - Great job in putting these comments together. I must admit, I was completely shocked to read that so many writers dont actually mind and, in fact, condone stealing of another writer's work. I guess I dont get it. I mean, how is it writing if one lifts entire passages from another author's work and claims such as their own? IS that not fraud? As noted, being inspired by another writers ideas and creating a completely unique story based on such is fine and even encouraged, but to steal another writers work word for word? Come on! What's next? Shall I cut the face out of the Mona Lisa, slap it to a poster board and tell the world I painted it? Geez! Happy Holidays - Steve

    danyel

    excellent responses. good reading. we're all over the place.

    dSW

    Bernita

    Some seem to wander into the superstitious region of Tabu in a neo-puritan attempt to cleanse any author's work of any influence, overt or not.
    At the same time, I tend to agree with Sue O'Neill that "respect" and "love" sounds much like the pedophile's defense.
    Margaret Atwood in "Negotiating with the Dead" in a disclaimer "any such notions ( of literary theory) that have wandered into this book have got there by the usual writerly methods, which resemble the ways of the jackdaw: we steal the shiny bits, and build them into the structures of our own disorderly nests."
    Seems to me that the issue is pretty clear. If one copies much more than a sentence from another protected writer without attribution, one has committed plagerism, caught or uncaught.
    With due respect for the arts of mitigation, all else is rationalization.
    And yes, the sky is blue and the devil is in the details.

    Pete

    Dan, excellent discussion on an important literary topic. Among my own stories are two potential offenders: one based on the Iroquois Theatre fire which has a quote from Anthony Hatch's "Tinder Box" as an epigraph (I obtained permission from the publisher); and one based on "Casey at the Bat" which includes Thayer's original poem in its entirety. I think I'm okay with the latter, since I acknowledged Thayer in an endnote; to the best of my knowledge, the original is also in the public domain.

    judy b.

    Well, as long as people are offering personal examples...

    Here's one I've published, trusting my readers to know the original, but if they don't, I don't think anyone's estate suffers. I've only read the original twice, years ago, and I can't imagine that I managed to replicate more than the spirit of it. You tell me. At anyrate, one college dean who read it was impressed and not incensed.

    http://tinyurl.com/9ygpg

    Henry Swanson

    [..] disclaimer: The following (sampled) quotes belong to nobody

    "I don't see like I'm breaking any rules.. because I don't see any rules to break." - Attributed to Bob Dylan

    "Exterminate all rational thought." - William Burroughs

    "La propriété, c'est le vol!" - Pierre-Joseph Proudhon

    "You are not a beautiful and unique snowflake" - Jill's Nipples

    "Sorry, I can't give you any reliable references for the impossible insubordination of words; they're indirectly unattributable to the non-stop evolutionary mutation of an ongoing critique of your dying world." - with love always, Henry Swanson

    ps. This comment, and eveything above and below it automatically released into the 'libre public domain.' Do what you have to but do it fast
    = = =

    The comments to this entry are closed.

    Best of the Web - Online Journals

    Blog powered by Typepad

    Sitemeter